POLL: What Do You Think Of The Choice For Pope?
Catholics and non-Catholics alike, we want your opinion
White smoke has risen from the chimney of the Sistine Chapel, signifying that two-thirds, or 77 of the 115 Cardinals eligible to vote, have agreed on the man to succeed Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI.
The Cardinals have elected Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Buenos Aires, Argentina, to lead the Catholic Church. To see a complete story, click here.
Bergoglio, who has chosen the name Francis I, is the first Pope from the Americas and the first Jesuit in Papal history and was the runner up behind Benedict in the last Papal Conclave.
A tweet from the Diocese of Trenton says:
"Pope Francis! Jesuit from Argentina...first Jesuit Pope and first Pope from the Americas!"
What do you think of the Cardinals' decision?
Tell Us: Which Cardinal would you have chosen to lead the Cathoic Church? Let us know in the comments below.
Tom Bolcar
3:56 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
I don't know enough about the man.
Vera Fozman
4:35 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
If you have ever visited Italy, you would know most of the jewlers hail from Argentina.
Theresa Dosch
4:44 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
I love the choice of Pope Francis! He is humble, has a servant's heart and I believe he will unite Catholics around the world with his humility and devout faith through service! His choosing of the name Francis speaks volumes! God bless him in his mission!
LC of Maine
5:02 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
What a lovely response Theresa...very well said!
carolyne morris
7:49 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
I am elated. I am overjoyed at the name he chose, St. Francis of Assisi, lover of animals, charitable and humble in nature. I love that he asked for a blessing from his sheep... and to see the people's faces on CNN last night, as collages of pictures were aired. It was an anointed and I feel he is going to be a special Pope who will be known throughout the coming ages. I wish him God's wisdom, strength, tolerance and Grace, as he enters his Papacy. I love that so many people Catholic or not, were at the very least intrigued by the whole process. Loved President's message to the new Pope. Very blessed day.
Sharon Anthony
4:59 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Don't know anything about the man but, it would be nice to see someone a little younger elected, someone who God willing would be able to serve longer than 8 years.
walt stevens
5:53 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Maybe the College of Cardinals doesn't want a new Pope with lengthy tenure.
Dame Bridgid
7:50 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
With his generosity of spirit, & simple faith even a short time will benefit the church. I hope our new Pope will be given to us for as long as possible, but I will be grateful to God for whatever time we are given with him. May the Holy Spirit strengthen Pope Francis, & grant him God's grace.
Cathy Boland
5:02 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
This unexpected selection could be just what is needed in our Church today. God Bless you, Pope Francis.
MTBottle
5:07 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
He wasn't who I had on the Pope pool. I'm out a few bucks but I like the name he chose. Saint Francis. Best of luck!!
carolyne morris
7:51 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
MTBottle - thanks for the chuckle. LOL!!!! Pope Pool!!!! LMAO!
PETER JONES
5:19 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
SEEMS TO BE AN EXCELLENT CHOICE- JESUIT AND SOUTH AMERICAN AND HUMBLE BUT POWERFUL. IT WOULD BE NICE IF HE COULD SHAKE UP THE CHURCH LIKE THE PREVIOUS POPE JOHN & HAVE ANOTHER VATICAN COUNCIL TO DEAL WITH THE GREAT ISSUES OF THE TIME- WOMEN CLERGY AND PERHAPS EVEN POPESSS, GAY RIGHTS AND MARRIAGE, BIRTH CONTROL, ETC.
Nj Ghost
6:07 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Hey peter!!! WOMEN CLERGY AND PERHAPS EVEN POPESSS, GAY RIGHTS AND MARRIAGE, BIRTH CONTROL, ETC.???? Really??? Just wondering if that is really you speaking or another part of your anatomy>>>>
Dame Bridgid
7:24 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
This Pope has the viewpoint that gay people are to be treated with love & respect. That would include the right to insurance, inheritance, joint burial, & medicine like any other pair.
However; a marriage in the Catholic church involves to people who join their souls & bodies to create a new life without breaking their marriage bond.
Sadly; even science cannot provide issue to a gay couple without going outside their biological union. The church sympathizes with the biological error they live with, but they cannot call such a union marriage.
A Catholic marriage is a sacred bond characterized by either biological offspring, or the possibility of biological offspring INSIDE the marriage. Infertile heterosexual couples qualify because there is a reasonable possibility that the Holy Spirit will intercede & a child could be born. Yes, The Holy Spirit still does miracles( I have the X-rays to prove that one).
Answer me this...Just where would a gay male gestate a baby in his body??? Where will the gay woman manufacture sperm???
Biology.
Dame Bridgid
7:27 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Sorry, I have spell check, not grammar check. That should read "two", not "to", just before the word 'people'.
Rick
5:20 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
I don't know too much about him but he sounds like a good choice.
mary
5:39 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Peter Jones, he's a Jesuit, so his training is fairly moderate/liberal, however he is traditional as far as marriage , birth control, etc. I'm just pleased that this choice seems to be of the holy spirit, not the politics. first non-european, first jesuit, first francis. wow! hoping he's like that other humble little man no one expected; john XXIII! I'm very hopeful today as a catholic!!
NBew Jersey Art
5:55 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
It seems that as far as dogma and doctrine, Pope Francis is rock solid. The Church will continue to hold fast to its core beliefs: life begins at conception, abortion is murder, women cannot be priests, homosexual behavior is sinful, etc. There may be changes in non-doctrinal matters such as priestly celibacy. On social issues, the Pope will continue and hopefully expand the Church's efforts to provide charity to the poor and the sick. No organization does more for the downtrodden than the Catholic Church. Since, as a Jesuit, he has taken a vow of poverty, I would not be surprised if he sold off some of the wealth of the Church to aid Catholic schools and to minister to the poor. As an outsider, the Pope will have the ability to clean up the Curia and the scandals at the Vatican Bank. He will continue to restore the reputation of the Church which was badly damaged by the predation of homosexual priests on post-pubescent boys. Although there have been virtually no new cases in the last twenty years, the fallout still continues. Although many people are thinking that he took the name, Francis, in order to emulate St. Francis of Assisi, it is equally likely that he will model his pontificate after St. Francis Xavier, a Jesuit missionary and the second most revered Jesuit saint after the founder of the order, St. Ignatius Loyola. Good times are ahead for the Church. It has to be that way - Christ promised to be with St. Peter and the Church until the end of the world.
Dame Bridgid
8:55 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Since the decision to stop priests from getting married in the 11th century was really a political & temporal power grab instigated by William the 1st of England & his brother (a Catholic bishop) to weaken the church... It may be deemed a restoration. The apostles, for the most part, were married.
The best way to handle it would be for Pope Francis to make the future vow one of chastity. Being married is not an unchaste state, nor is producing offspring within that marriage.
I feel this pope is highly educated, & humble enough to correct it as a historical misstep.
Rick
3:49 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
One of the main reasons for the celibacy ruling was that many clerics and in particular those that became bishops, cardinals and popes were from wealthy families.
If they had wives and children they would leave their wealth to them rather than to the Church.
Many early popes had wives and children, including St Peter, the first pope.
Pope Saint Hormisdas was married and his son became Pope Saint Silverius.
Betty Torode
5:56 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
He's already breaking with tradition. 1st Jesuit. 1st Francis. 1st non-European Pope. 1st Pope in my lifetime to greet the world in simple cassock and not the regal robes of his predecessors. Opted not to accept the "perks" of a Bishop and opted to use public transportation, live in an apartment and cooked for self according to the news. Greeted all in St Peter's Square and asked them to go home to rest and prepare for the new day tomorrow. Seems to be humble and caring as he has strived to understand the needs of the struggling. Hoping he will be the vessel that the Holy Spirit will use to heal our church.
Carl Wilton
6:34 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
If a sympathetic Protestant may be allowed to comment, let me echo what others have said above about the name Francis (whether Francis of Assisi or Francis Xavier) boding well for the future.
With respect to the Francis of Assisi, a well-known (but likely apocryphal) story comes to mind - and gives me hope for a new style of papal leadership. When Francis of Assisi had an audience with Pope Innocent III, the pope took that apostle of simple living on a tour through the Vatican treasury. Proudly showing off the wealth of the medieval church, the pope said (citing Peter's and John's healing of the paralyzed beggar in Acts 3): "See, the church can no longer say, 'silver and gold have I none.'"
Francis replied: "Yes, but can it still say, 'Rise up and walk'?"
Acts 3:6 - "But Peter said, 'I have no silver or gold, but what I have I give you; in the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, stand up and walk.'"
Let's pray that this pope will be able to lead not only the Roman church, but also (by example) all God's people, in a powerful witness of peace and justice.
carolyne morris
7:59 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
carlwilton-how wise you are... as a Cathoiic, devoted to the Blessed Trinity and lover of my faith... I can appreciate your insight and feel the same way. I believe a majority of Catholics feel that the church has lost touch a bit with the Divine message. I pray diligently that this Pope can turn it around and bring us back to Christ's teachings, His message to Love and Honor God above ALL things and Love Your Neighbor As You Love Yourself. We need to return to simplicity-in sharing the Gospel, Evangelization and helping others.
Dame Bridgid
6:41 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
I think this is a Pope who is outside the usual.
Imagine a cardinal living in a small apartment; cooking for himself, & taking public transport. One with a history of caring about the poor. He once chastised priests who would not baptize an illegitimate baby, because the baby was innocent of sin & deserved God's blessing. I like that.
The name Francis is synonymous with peace & justice.
It looks like we have a Pope from a cardinal who follows Christ humbly. May he continue to cleanse the church, & help us all to become better people through his example. A very good choice in my opinion. I wish I was well enough to go celebrate.
carolyne morris
12:40 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Dame Bridgid, well said! When I heard that he chastised priests for not accepting and baptizing babies born out of wedlock I cheered and cried... my family has been affected twice by the same judgmental decision to tell parents (who chose life) they are not welcomed into the church community. Jesus said, Let the children come to me." He did not say, "Only the ones with married parents!"
I was estranged from the Catholic Church for a long time until God's will brought me back "home". Now I am devoted, as I have been taught (by God, Holy Spirit) that the people in church are human, likely to fail, likely to sin...but if you can find the Blessed Trinity in the midst of the human frailty, you will find your "church". We worship in spirit and in truth.
God bless us all, as we look forward to whatever GOD brings thru His newly-elected representative.
trishmontenegro
7:40 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Sad to say pope Francis is a conservative. He led a movement against gay marriage is an antiabortionist and is anything but modern. Last year he did How ever during a lentil service, wash the feet of gay men. If your not Catholic you would not understand.
When John paul 2 died they decided they wanted someone older because he was 58 when he became pope. That is why we got Ben. A younger pope does not make for younger ideas. Pope John 23 was a complete reformer who probably would have allowed a great deal of the things we wanted. Maybe they should only have a 10 year term.
Just don't expect too much of a change. The Cardinals elect who they want, not what we want.
Maybe he will see the light and God helps him address the issues that we feel are important.
Nj Ghost
8:36 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Trish, you do alot of "WE" in that statement....I don't know what issues are important to you but I know what issues are important to me.....You stick with your "WE" and until I know what they are I'll stick with mine.
Dame Bridgid
10:00 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Trish, a gay union is biologically sterile.
In the Catholic church a marriage produces the fruit of offspring, or the possibility of them between the couple(without violation of their marriage vows of chastity towards each other). A miracle is still possible to infertile heterosexuals(like Elizabeth, the mother of John the Baptist).
It is sad for gays, but I feel civil unions can provide all the legal protection. I want them to have equal legal protection I, like my church, & do sincerely care for the distress their affliction brings them, but do not presume to speak for me.
Less than a third of Americans in general approve of abortion on demand now, & the numbers have been steadily dropping for over a decade. My childless sister regrets she never got another chance to bear another child after rejecting the first healthy one for convenience. As for me, I turned down emergency lung surgery for a collapsed lung to preserve my 20 week pregnancy. She has dimples & a college degree, please do not speak for me.
You must not attend the Catholic church much. Are you an 'Ashes & Holly' type of girl, or a 'cafeteria' catholic attending your "LENTIL" services.
What I feel is important in my church, you cannot speak for.
Your 'we' does not include me.
Dame Bridgid
10:03 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Sorry, I forgot to delete the ampersand(&) in my 6th sentence.
William J Moss
7:48 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
God Bless him and guide him. Long live the pope.
Dame Bridgid
10:07 pm on Wednesday, March 13, 2013
A promising new Pope, & a good day. Time for me to say Goodnight to everyone. God's grace to you all.
whatsnotwrong
1:16 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
a little rough on Trish guys
Dame Bridgid
9:34 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
I probably should have put a smiley face after the 'lentil' pun, but can you fairly say she represents the entire body of the Catholic church with her "we"?
Rick
5:51 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Pope gets elected!
Promises nothing.
No health care.
No cell phones.
No welfare.
... No citizenship.
No chicken in any pot.
Yet, when he speaks the entire world stops and listens!
Nj Ghost
7:13 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
The mystery of faith I guess.
Max
6:02 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Another Election and nothing will change, I do not know why People get so excited about this!!!!
Frank Pagano
7:36 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
How many other organizations have lasted 2000 years?
Ray
8:28 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
If you read his background, he did nothing to prevent the Argentine Junta to terrorize and kill many citizens. Only 10% of Catholics in Argentina attend Mass. He will continue the present policies against abortion, gay marriage and celibicy. and the Church will not modernize during his reign. Hence, more Catholics will be leaving.
Dame Bridgid
10:26 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Face it, Ray;
(1) the 5th commandment in the Catholic bible says do not kill. There is an exception to for self defense or in the defense of others.
Now talk about aborting your own offspring, a helpless innocent who has committed no crime against you.
(2) Catholic Marriage includes offspring or the hope of offspring for infertile couples who can conceive like Elizabeth (John the Baptist's mother) through divine intervention. Catholic marriage has a vow of chastity( cleaving only unto the spouse) to live as one body, one spirit, united to create a new life.
Two men are sterile when they join their bodies. Two women are sterile when they join their bodies. Argue with a biologist to change that law of nature, it makes as much sense.
(3) Celibacy might change. If he has time while dealing with all the other problems. There is Apostolic precedent to support it, & Jesuits are very well educated, as well as being devoted to justice.
(4) How many Catholics there are now is not related to his ability.
(5) Just what do you think he & that 10% of Catholics in church could have done, other than speak out(he did).
I guess you have everyone's mind made up, right? Sorry, I am not leaving.
Cleaning up the messes that really drove people away might bring people back. I will wait to see what will happen with hope. For now; I simply thank The Holy Spirit for Pope Francis who kept his own vows to God by taking the bus, & living a simple life as a Cardinal.
Dame Bridgid
11:00 am on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Sorry, my sentence should have said "There is an Exception for self defense or in the defense of others." Delete the word 'to' from it.
Rick
3:12 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Actually Dame B, in both Exodus and Deuteronomy the commandant was originally "You shall not murder". There is a difference between murder and other forms of killing.
A short time after they received the 10 Commandments, the Israelites fought the Battle of Jericho. That was the first of many battles the Israelites fought on their way into Canaan.
Deuteronomy repeats the original 10 Commandmends and list over 500 others, including several which assign stoning as punishment.
Rick
3:32 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Hey Ray, where did you get that statistic?
Ray
12:29 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Dame, let me clarify, I am against abortion and gay marriage, but I think priests should be allowed to marry. It would prevent a lot of pedophiles from becoming priests which has caused many Catholics to leave.
Dame Bridgid
6:38 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
I agree priests should marry, Ray. Removing that sacrament was a political move in the 11th century to weaken the body of the church. I think it did.
The apostles Jesus chose were mostly married men. Paul of Tarsus did not know Christ during his ministry (before or after the resurrection) so I view what he has to say as his own self appointed opinion.
I favor changing the vow to chastity rather than celibacy. Marriage is not an unchaste state. My husband of 30 years has sired 6 children with me, whilst keeping himself chaste by abiding by our marriage vows, as I have. Allowing priests to have families will lead to an increase in faith. Children learn what they live ;)
Just remember we have been rooting out abusers now by teaching church members how to spot them, responding to victims, & reporting them to police. They exist in all groups. Continued effort will always be needed to deny evil an opportunity to grow. Religions with married clergy have the same abuse problems that require action. We need to continue our current vigilance to catch abusers who try to sneak into our church in the future.
John miller
2:11 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Who cares?
Nj Ghost
9:41 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Who Cares John? Every parent cares John, every parent and every adult who sees the beauty and innocence of a child, that's who cares.....Perhaps you yourself have a pent up problem with children that you might like to discuss with perhaps a doctor or the authorities for that matter. I have a really bad feeling for people like you John, a real bad feeling.
PPNB
4:08 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Dogmatic cares.
John Paglione
5:45 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
An Excellent choice. He will be a Pope, not just for the people but of the people.
Richard head
8:43 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Hey John nice use of a line from a historical document. Your a tool.
Rick
2:49 pm on Sunday, March 17, 2013
What historic document are you refering to?